I am going by Wikipedia so there may be a few missing. I marked a star next to the one's I have (so I have a checklist for myself too!)
Without further ado, here we go:
List of "Fear Street" books in the order of when they were published
"The New Girl" *
"The Surprise Party" *
"The Overnight" *
"Missing" *
"The Wrong Number" *
"The Sleepwalker" *
"Haunted"
"Halloween Party" *
"The Stepsister" *
"Ski Weekend" *
"The Fire Game"
"Lights Out"
"The Secret Bedroom"
"The Knife" *
"The Prom Queen" *
"First Date" *
"The Best Friend"
"The Cheater" *
"Sunburn"
"The New Boy" *
"The Dare" *
"Bad Dreams"
"Double Date"
"The Thrill Club"*
"One Evil Summer"
"The Mind Reader" *
"Wrong Number 2"
"Truth or Dare" *
"Dead End" *
"Final Grade" *
"Switched" *
"College Weekend" *
"The Stepsister 2"
"What Holly Heard"
"The Face" *
"Secret Admirer"
"The Perfect Date"
"The Confession" *
"The Boy Next Door" *
"Night Games"
"Runaway" *
"Killer's Kiss"
"All-Night Party" *
"The Rich Girl" *
"Cat"
"Fear Hall: The Beginning"
"Fear Hall: The Conclusion"
"Who Killed the Homecoming Queen?" *
"Into the Dark"
"Best Friend 2"
"Trapped"
The Stepbrother"
"Camp Out"
"Scream Jennifer, Scream!"
"The Bad Girl"
"Party Games"
"Don't Stay Up Late"
"The Lost Girl"
"Party Summer" *
"Silent Night" *
"Goodnight Kiss" *
"Broken Hearts" *
"Silent Night 2"
"The Dead Lifeguard" *
"Cheerleaders: The New Evil"
"Bad Moonlight"
"The New Year's Party"
"Goodnight Kiss 2" *
"Silent Night 3"
"High Tide"
"Cheerleaders: The Evil Lives!"
"The First Evil" *
"The Second Evil"
"The Third Evil"
"The Betrayal" *
"The Secret" *
"The Burning"
"The First Horror" *
"The Second Horror"
"The Third Horror" *
"The Evil Moon"
"The Dark Secret"
"The Deadly Fire"
"The First Scream"
"The Loudest Scream"
"The Last Scream"
"A New Fear" *
"House of Whispers" *
"Forbidden Secrets" *
"The Sign of Fear" *
"The Hidden Evil"
"Daughters of Silence"
"Children of Fear"
"Dance of Death"
"Heart of the Hunter"
"The Awakening Evil"
"Circle of Fire"
"Chamber of Fear"
"Faces of Terror"
"One Last Kiss"
"Door of Death"
"The Hand of Power"
"Silent Night" *
"Goodnight Kiss" *
"Broken Hearts" *
"Silent Night 2"
"The Dead Lifeguard" *
"Cheerleaders: The New Evil"
"Bad Moonlight"
"The New Year's Party"
"Goodnight Kiss 2" *
"Silent Night 3"
"High Tide"
"Cheerleaders: The Evil Lives!"
"The First Evil" *
"The Second Evil"
"The Third Evil"
"The Betrayal" *
"The Secret" *
"The Burning"
"The First Horror" *
"The Second Horror"
"The Third Horror" *
"The Evil Moon"
"The Dark Secret"
"The Deadly Fire"
"The First Scream"
"The Loudest Scream"
"The Last Scream"
"A New Fear" *
"House of Whispers" *
"Forbidden Secrets" *
"The Sign of Fear" *
"The Hidden Evil"
"Daughters of Silence"
"Children of Fear"
"Dance of Death"
"Heart of the Hunter"
"The Awakening Evil"
"Circle of Fire"
"Chamber of Fear"
"Faces of Terror"
"One Last Kiss"
"Door of Death"
"The Hand of Power"
"The Raven Woman"
"Carousel of Fear" ?? (not sure if this was published)
"Let's Party!"
"In Too Deep"
"The Thirst"
"No Answer"
"Last Chance"
"The Gift"
"Fight, Team, Fight!"
"Sweetheart, Evil Heart"
"Spring Break"
"Wicked"
"The Prom Date"
"Graduation Day"
"Moonlight Secrets"
"Midnight Games"
"Darkest Dawn" *
"Carousel of Fear" ?? (not sure if this was published)
"Let's Party!"
"In Too Deep"
"The Thirst"
"No Answer"
"Last Chance"
"The Gift"
"Fight, Team, Fight!"
"Sweetheart, Evil Heart"
"Spring Break"
"Wicked"
"The Prom Date"
"Graduation Day"
"Moonlight Secrets"
"Midnight Games"
"Darkest Dawn" *
